Statement Of Dr. Michael Oppenheimer Chief Scientist, Environmental Defense
The Kyoto Protocol was added to the UN Framework Convention on Climate Change (signed at the Earth Summit in Rio de Janiero in 1992) because most countries, particularly the US, were failing to meet their Rio commitments. The very basis of the Kyoto Protocol is that its obligations were intended to be binding. The key reason why the Rio agreement failed was that obligations were described as voluntary rather than binding. Potential for success under the Kyoto protocol depends on its obligations being binding. Equally important, these obligations were expressed explicitly in terms of absolute caps on emissions; they were not expressed in terms of level-of-effort, financial or otherwise.
Language in the current text would turn the basic obligation to limit emissions into an obligation to merely put in a “level of effort” denominated in dollars., which would allow a Party to avoid binding consequences for non-compliance. Rather than compel Parties to remedy non-compliance with carbon cuts sufficient to fully compensate for excess emissions, the result of the proposed “compliance fund” could be a pay-to-pollute approach wherein non-complying Parties would pay a limited amount into a fund to buy their way out of commitments. There would be no absolute obligation to ever restore carbon levels in the atmosphere to the Protocol’s required levels, whether by directly reducing national emissions, adopting prescribed compliance action plans, using a financial mechanism that reduces emissions, or any other means to reduce emissions.
The result would be rampant non-compliance, failure to meet Kyoto obligations, and ultimately, the failure of the Protocol. In short, this would be a stealth re-negotiation of the Kyoto Protocol. Yet there is no evidence that this approach would further the likelihood of ratification.
One of the world’s leading international nonprofit organizations, Environmental Defense Fund (edf.org) creates transformational solutions to the most serious environmental problems. To do so, EDF links science, economics, law, and innovative private-sector partnerships. With more than 3 million members and offices in the United States, China, Mexico, Indonesia and the European Union, EDF’s scientists, economists, attorneys and policy experts are working in 28 countries to turn our solutions into action. Connect with us on Twitter @EnvDefenseFund
Latest press releases
-
EDF statement on COP29 outcome, new climate finance goal, Article 6
November 24, 2024 -
Historic Article 6 Decision at COP29 – After Much Debate, a Reasoned Solution
November 23, 2024 -
Russ Vought Nominated for Office of Management and Budget Director
November 23, 2024 -
Action on Pathways Initiative Proposal Will Boost Affordable, Reliable Clean Energy
November 22, 2024 -
EPA Acts to Reduce Dangerous Air Pollution from New Gas-Burning Power Plants
November 22, 2024 -
New York MTA receives final federal approvals for congestion pricing
November 22, 2024